Menu
Introduction: In the 2024 NFL season, three names are unexpectedly making waves: Derek Carr, Sam Darnold, and Baker Mayfield. Each quarterback has stepped up to lead their respective teams, making them key contenders in their divisions. Fans and analysts alike are surprised to see these players — once dismissed as mid-tier QBs — now sitting at the helm of some of the league’s most impressive offenses. Through the first two weeks of the season, these players have posted eye-popping statistics that force us to reconsider their status among the NFL’s elite. Let’s dive into what’s making these quarterbacks stand out, how their teams are performing, and what the future holds.
As mentioned in the podcast, Derek Carr, Sam Darnold, and Baker Mayfield are not just winning games; they are putting up exceptional numbers. Derek Carr leads in QBR, passing touchdowns, and completion percentage, while Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold are close behind in multiple categories.
Each quarterback has led their team to a 2-0 start. For context:
This early success positions each team as a front-runner in their division. Carr’s Saints and Mayfield’s Buccaneers are leading the NFC South, while Darnold’s Vikings sit atop the NFC North.
While some critics argue that the strength of schedule has benefited these quarterbacks, especially Darnold, who faced the Giants, and Carr, who faced the Panthers, Mayfield has arguably had the toughest schedule. Beating the Detroit Lions in a playoff rematch and securing a victory over the Commanders are no small feats. As we move forward into week three, these quarterbacks will face even stiffer competition, giving us a clearer picture of their long-term viability.
Carr’s transition to the Saints has been seamless, with him leading the league in multiple statistical categories, such as:
Carr’s ability to quickly adapt to Clint Kubiak’s offensive scheme is impressive. He’s shown poise, especially in critical moments, and his precision passing has been a key factor in the Saints’ success.
Darnold has been the biggest surprise of 2024. After struggling early in his career, he’s revitalized his game under head coach Kevin O’Connell.
Critics may argue that his opponents thus far haven’t been strong, but Darnold’s consistent performances show that he’s capable of leading the Vikings through a challenging season.
Mayfield’s second year with Tampa Bay has him looking more polished than ever. His experience and chemistry with the team are paying dividends.
His performance against tough opponents like the Lions and Commanders has turned heads, showing that Mayfield is more than just a game manager—he’s a leader.
The next few weeks will test the true mettle of these quarterbacks.
Each quarterback owes part of their success to their coaching staff:
Through two weeks, Carr, Darnold, and Mayfield have made a compelling case as top 10 quarterbacks in the league. Week 3 will bring even greater challenges, and how they perform will help solidify or diminish their early-season successes. What we do know is that these three have surprised everyone, and the 2024 NFL season is shaping up to be a career-defining moment for each of them.
Loved our breakdown? Don’t miss an episode of the GSMC Chip Shot Football Podcast! Subscribe now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube for the latest NFL news and analysis. Drop us a review, share your thoughts on social media, and head over to gsmcpodcast.com for more in-depth articles like this!
