Menu
As the NFL season hits the halfway point, the spotlight is on the league’s promising rookie class, many of whom are already making a significant impact. From quarterbacks leading their teams to victories to running backs and receivers breaking out as key contributors, the future of the NFL is looking brighter than ever. In the latest episode of *Sports by GSMC*, host Jeremy Leas dives deep into the Week 9 Rookie Report, examining standout performances from across the league. With so many talented young players stepping up, it’s clear that this year’s rookie class is full of potential.
This week’s rookie breakdown is especially exciting, as some unexpected names have risen to the top, while a few others have shown flashes of brilliance but have yet to fully establish themselves. From Caleb Williams’ struggles with the Chicago Bears to Jaden Daniels’ continued dominance with the Washington Commanders, there are plenty of storylines to follow. Additionally, the midseason awards are starting to take shape, and rookie performances will play a key role in determining which players take home the coveted honors.
As we look at the top five rookies of Week 9, it’s clear that the competition for Offensive Rookie of the Year is heating up. While players like Jaden Daniels and Drake May are making a strong case, others, such as Ray Davis and Romo Dun, are proving that they belong among the league’s best newcomers. In this article, we’ll break down the top performances, highlight the honorable mentions, and look ahead at the midseason awards as the NFL season continues to unfold. Whether you’re a diehard fan or a casual observer, these young stars are sure to make waves for years to come.
Before diving into the top five rookie performances of Week 9, we have a few notable honorable mentions worth discussing.
Caleb Williams (QB – Chicago Bears)
Once considered a potential Offensive Rookie of the Year contender, Caleb Williams has faced setbacks in recent weeks. Despite his efforts, the Bears’ overall struggles are evident, and Williams has slipped out of the top five for the second consecutive week. His Week 9 stats – 22 completions for 217 yards with no touchdowns or interceptions – highlight his solid, but unspectacular play. While Williams isn’t to blame for his team’s lackluster performance, it’s clear that the Bears have plenty of work to do around him.
Bo Nix (QB – Denver Broncos)
Bo Nix, who had impressed earlier in the season, now sits firmly in the honorable mentions. He had a decent showing in Week 9, going 19 for 33 with 233 passing yards, one interception, and a receiving touchdown. However, Nix’s lack of a significant impact and some key mistakes on offense keep him from cracking the top five this week.
Malik Neighbors (WR – New York Giants)
With nine catches, Malik Neighbors has been a steady presence in the Giants’ offense since returning from concussion protocol. However, his lack of yardage (under 60 yards) this week has him staying in the honorable mentions. While Neighbors continues to impress in volume, his lack of explosive plays limits his rise.
Lad Makoni (WR – Los Angeles Chargers)
Lad Makoni, another rookie receiver, had a solid performance with five catches for 64 yards. He continues to be a crucial part of the Chargers’ offense, showing promise as a playmaker, but he’s still not making the sort of game-breaking plays that would elevate him into the top five rankings.
While these rookies have shown flashes of talent, they have not yet fully asserted themselves as the game-changers we expect from elite rookies.
Now, let’s dive into the top performances from Week 9. These rookies have displayed not only individual brilliance but have contributed significantly to their team’s success.
Tyrone Tracy’s performance might not have been jaw-dropping, but it was solid enough to secure him a spot in the top five this week. With 16 carries for 66 yards and a catch for three yards, Tracy was the Giants’ primary ball carrier. This was his second game as the full-time starter, and while his performance wasn’t spectacular, it was still better than many of his peers. The Giants’ offense continues to struggle, but Tracy’s consistency and ability to keep the chains moving make him a player to keep an eye on moving forward.
Romo Dun continues to make strides in his rookie season. In Week 9, he cracked the 100-yard mark for the second time in his career. Despite Caleb Williams and the Bears’ struggles on offense, Dun has emerged as a reliable target. His performances may not have been flashy, but his steady improvement and increased target share (especially with DJ Moore’s struggles) suggest that he could become a key figure in Chicago’s rebuilding process. With more opportunities, Dun could easily see his stock rise.
Ray Davis has been one of the most intriguing rookies of late. In Week 9, he showcased his explosiveness with a long touchdown catch and was a key part of the Bills’ offense. Davis’s performance is becoming increasingly important for Buffalo’s offense as a change-of-pace back. While James Cook remains the Bills’ primary runner, Davis’s ability to create big plays in the passing game and on the ground has added a new dimension to their backfield. With his steady rise, Davis is beginning to look like one of the best rookie additions of the season.
Drake May’s Week 9 performance was one for the history books, particularly with his unforgettable game-winning play in overtime. His 29 completions for 206 yards, combined with 95 rushing yards, exemplify his dual-threat capabilities. The highlight of his game came at the tail end of regulation, where he evaded multiple defenders to deliver a perfect throw to the end zone, tying the game and ultimately leading the Patriots to victory. May’s poise under pressure and ability to make plays with both his arm and legs have made him a key part of the Patriots’ future. While New England’s immediate future might still be in question, May’s growth is a promising sign.
At the top of our Week 9 Rookie Report is Jaden Daniels, who has continued to dominate as one of the best rookies in the NFL this season. His 15 completions on 22 attempts for 209 yards and two touchdowns were impressive enough, but it’s his consistent ability to make smart plays and avoid turnovers that stands out. Daniels’ performance against the New York Giants was nothing short of spectacular. His poise, accuracy, and leadership have led Washington to a strong 7-2 record. With his ability to lead the Commanders to victories week in and week out, Daniels is quickly emerging as one of the most exciting quarterbacks in the league. He’s earned our top rookie honors for Week 9—and it’s hard to imagine anyone surpassing him anytime soon.
As we reach the halfway point of the NFL season, it’s time to take stock of the performances that could shape the year-end awards. In addition to the weekly rookie rankings, we also discuss predictions for key midseason awards.
NFL MVP: Patrick Mahomes and Tua Tagovailoa continue to be at the forefront of the MVP conversation, but Jalen Hurts has made a strong case with the Eagles’ excellent record.
Offensive Rookie of the Year: Jaden Daniels remains the frontrunner, but the performances of Drake May and Ray Davis are closing the gap.
Defensive Rookie of the Year: The rookie defensive class has some standouts, including players like Jalen Carter (Philadelphia Eagles) and Christian Gonzalez (New England Patriots).
As the season progresses, these rookie performances will continue to shape the NFL landscape, with several young players positioning themselves for both individual and team success.
The NFL’s rookie class has provided fans with plenty of exciting moments through the first half of the season. With players like Jaden Daniels, Ray Davis, and Drake May leading the charge, the future of the league is in good hands. As we approach the second half of the season, all eyes will be on how these young players develop and whether they can maintain their high level of play.
Stay tuned for more updates on the NFL Rookie Report and other breaking sports news, and make sure to catch the full Sports by GSMC episode on YouTube and your favorite podcast platforms.
Enjoyed this breakdown of NFL rookies and midseason awards? Stay updated on the latest sports news by subscribing to the Sports by GSMC podcast! You can also engage with us on social media, leave a review, and check out more of our exclusive content on GSMC Sports Network YouTube Channel and GSMC Podcast Website.
Let us know your thoughts—who’s your pick for Rookie of the Year so far? Drop a comment, share the post, and keep the sports conversation going!
