NFC First-Round Rookie Grades
1. Caleb Williams, QB – Chicago Bears
Grade: D
Caleb Williams, the number one overall pick, had a challenging debut against the Tennessee Titans. Williams’ performance was far below the high expectations set for him, with a completion rate of just 14 of 29 passes and only 93 yards. His struggles were evident, as he missed several open throws and made poor decisions, particularly in taking unnecessary sacks. Despite this rough start, there’s confidence that Williams will adjust and improve as he gains more experience.
2. Jaden Daniels, QB – Washington Commanders
Grade: B
Jaden Daniels, the second overall pick, had a solid debut with some promising aspects. He completed 17 of 24 passes for 184 yards and added 88 rushing yards with two touchdowns. While his passing game wasn’t spectacular, Daniels’ mobility and ability to make plays with his legs were notable. His performance indicated that he could develop into a key player for the Commanders, though improvements in his passing game will be essential.
3. Marvin Harrison Jr., WR – Arizona Cardinals
Grade: C-
Marvin Harrison Jr., drafted fourth overall, had a disappointing start with only one reception. The Cardinals’ game plan heavily favored the run, limiting Harrison’s opportunities. Additionally, there were issues with how plays were designed for him. Despite this quiet debut, Harrison’s talent is undeniable, and it’s expected that he will make significant contributions as the season progresses.
4. Malik Neighbors, WR – New York Giants
Grade: B
Malik Neighbors, another top wide receiver from the draft, made a strong impression in his debut. He recorded five catches for 66 yards on seven targets. Neighbors showcased his route-running skills and speed, proving to be a valuable asset in the Giants’ offense. If he continues to develop, he could become a cornerstone for the team’s receiving corps.
5. Radun, OL – Chicago Bears
Grade: Incomplete
Radun’s debut was cut short due to an MCL sprain, so a full evaluation of his performance isn’t possible. Before his injury, he played in the game but didn’t make a significant impact. It remains to be seen how quickly he will recover and what his role will be once he returns to the field.
6. Tallis Fuaga, OT – Carolina Panthers
Grade: A
Tallis Fuaga had an impressive debut, particularly in pass protection. He allowed no pressures and played a key role in the Panthers’ offensive line. While the Panthers’ opponent was the Carolina Panthers’ defense, Fuaga’s flawless performance was a standout. His strong showing suggests he could be a key player moving forward.
7. Byron Murphy II, DT – Minnesota Vikings
Grade: C
Byron Murphy II had a mixed debut, contributing a few tackles and pressures. While his impact wasn’t overwhelming, there were positive signs. Murphy’s performance suggests he has potential, but further consistency will be required to make a more definitive assessment.
8. Dallas Turner, EDGE – Minnesota Vikings
Grade: B
Dallas Turner recorded his first career sack and showed promise in his debut. He was effective in the pass rush but had limited reps due to the Vikings’ depth at the position. Turner’s athleticism was evident, and he’s expected to grow into a significant defensive presence.
9. Jared Verse, EDGE – Los Angeles Rams
Grade: C+
Jared Verse had a solid first half but was less effective in the second. He recorded a sack but struggled with run defense and positioning at times. There are areas for improvement, especially in maintaining consistent pressure and run defense, but Verse’s potential is clear.
10. Kinion Mitchell, CB – Philadelphia Eagles
Grade: C
Kinion Mitchell faced a tough test in his debut, being targeted 10 times and allowing 86 yards. He had two pass deflections but also showed some vulnerabilities. It’s a mixed bag for Mitchell, who will need to improve his coverage to become a more reliable cornerback.
11. Terion Arnold, CB – Detroit Lions
Grade: B-
Terion Arnold had a commendable debut, particularly in the first half. He matched up against elite receiver Cooper Kupp and held his own, despite some pass interference calls. Arnold’s performance was promising, and he’s likely to be a key part of the Lions’ secondary moving forward.
12. Jordan Morgan, OL – Green Bay Packers
Grade: C
Jordan Morgan had a solid but unspectacular debut. He came in as a substitute and performed adequately in pass protection. While his performance was average, there is room for growth, and he could improve as he gains more experience.
13. Graham Barton, C – Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Grade: B-
Graham Barton had an overall
