Menu
As college football season continues to heat up, the College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings are under intense scrutiny. Each week, the selection committee evaluates teams based on performance, strength of schedule, and overall impact. With the third CFP ranking released, fans and analysts alike have been quick to weigh in, offering their opinions on what’s right, what’s wrong, and what could use a second look. As the playoff picture begins to take shape, it’s clear that the rankings have sparked lively debate, especially when it comes to the teams that just missed the cut or those that might have been given too much credit.
In this blog, we’ll dive deep into the latest CFP rankings, dissecting each of the top-ranked teams and those just outside the playoff bubble. From the surprise appearances of lower-ranked teams to the snubs that left fans frustrated, this analysis will highlight what the committee got right and where they might have gone astray. As we explore the rankings from 25 to 1, we’ll examine the strengths and weaknesses of each team’s position, with particular focus on teams like Illinois, Missouri, and Iowa State, who sparked considerable debate in the latest poll.
Furthermore, we’ll explore the growing influence of Group of Five teams, such as Boise State and Tulane, who continue to challenge the notion that only Power Five programs belong in the playoff conversation. With a more competitive landscape, the potential for chaos in the next few weeks is high, and it’s anyone’s guess which teams will ultimately secure their place in the College Football Playoff. Let’s break down the third rankings of the season and see how the committee is shaping the path to the playoff.
The top five in the latest College Football Playoff rankings largely remained unchanged, much to the approval of many college football fans. The playoff committee continued to recognize the dominance of established programs, with Alabama, Ole Miss, and Georgia leading the pack. These programs have established themselves as the powerhouses of college football, and the ranking committee’s decision to maintain this order reflects their consistent performance on the field. One notable point of debate, however, is how the SEC continues to dominate the rankings. The committee has largely placed SEC teams at the forefront, with Alabama sitting at No. 1, Georgia at No. 3, and Tennessee just on the outside looking in at No. 11.
Alabama’s top ranking is particularly important, as they have remained a perennial contender under head coach Nick Saban. The Crimson Tide’s strength of schedule and recent performances have justified their place at No. 1, despite some challenges throughout the season. Similarly, Georgia, while not ranked at the top, has maintained their position as one of the most powerful teams in the nation. The Bulldogs’ place in the top five is a reflection of their impressive defense and continued success in the SEC.
While the top five mostly follows expectations, the rest of the rankings have raised some eyebrows. One of the most controversial decisions has been the placement of Illinois, Missouri, and Iowa State. These teams have made their way into the top 25, but several college football enthusiasts have voiced concerns over their rankings. Illinois, at No. 25, has not shown enough dominance to justify being included in the top 25. While they have a solid record, their schedule hasn’t included many top-tier teams. More importantly, they’ve struggled in high-pressure games, and their resume doesn’t quite match up with some other deserving programs.
Missouri at No. 23 and Iowa State at No. 22 also seem to be over-ranked, considering the talent of other schools that have been left out of the top 25. These teams, while competitive, have failed to impress in key matchups and could easily be bumped down the rankings in favor of other teams with stronger resumes. In particular, Missouri’s placement ahead of a team like Syracuse, which has been more consistent in the top 25, feels like a missed opportunity for the selection committee to reward a more deserving program.
Moving further down the rankings, two teams that deserve more attention are Arizona State and Tulane. Both teams have proven their mettle this season, but the rankings haven’t fully reflected their achievements. Arizona State’s strength of schedule has been one of the toughest in the country, and despite facing some elite programs, they have remained competitive. Their place at No. 21 is certainly earned, but they might be more deserving of a higher spot.
Tulane, often overlooked in discussions of college football powerhouses, is another team that has earned the right to be higher. As arguably the best Group of Five team this season, Tulane has impressed with both its offense and defense. Their ranking at No. 20 is respectable but falls short of giving them the recognition they deserve for their success. In fact, Tulane’s performance could make them a legitimate contender for a major bowl game if they continue to perform well in their conference.
At No. 16, Colorado has sparked considerable interest, mainly because of Coach Deion Sanders’ impact on the program. Coach Prime has brought a level of excitement and talent to Colorado that has garnered national attention. While the Buffaloes have faced their share of setbacks, including tough losses to higher-ranked opponents, their overall performance and growth under Sanders cannot be overlooked. Some believe that Colorado deserves to be ranked even higher, especially given their potential to cause upsets in the coming weeks.
Boise State, currently ranked No. 12, represents another interesting case. The Mountain West champion has earned a first-round bye in the playoff picture, which is a significant achievement for a Group of Five team. However, many college football fans argue that Boise State might not be as strong as teams like Colorado, who have proven themselves in a tougher conference. While Boise State has had an impressive season, their strength of schedule hasn’t been as robust as some other teams, which raises questions about whether they truly deserve a bye over teams from more competitive conferences.
One of the most contentious debates surrounding the College Football Playoff rankings is the SEC’s claim to five spots in the top 25. As it stands, Alabama, Ole Miss, Georgia, and Tennessee are the four SEC teams in the top 11, with Tennessee being the “odd man out” as the first team just outside of the playoff race. Some argue that the SEC has earned its place as the most competitive conference in college football, but others believe that it’s time to give more opportunities to teams from other conferences, especially considering the strength of teams like Notre Dame, Ohio State, and Michigan in the Big Ten.
The argument for having five SEC teams in the top 25 is based on the conference’s overall dominance in the sport, with multiple teams consistently vying for national titles. However, while the SEC deserves respect for its top-tier programs, it remains a point of contention whether they should continue to dominate the rankings at the expense of other deserving teams. The inclusion of Tennessee at No. 11 further fuels this debate, especially as the team’s position has been criticized by those who feel they’re still too close to the playoff race, despite some earlier losses.
With only a few weeks left in the regular season, the playoff picture is far from settled. Teams like Alabama, Georgia, and Ole Miss look poised to make a deep run into the playoff, but surprises can always happen in college football. The CFP rankings have sparked lively discussions about the fairness of the committee’s decisions, but it’s clear that the committee has put thought into balancing strength of schedule, head-to-head matchups, and overall performance when crafting the rankings.
For fans, the college football playoff rankings are just the beginning of the conversation. As the season progresses, teams like Arizona State, Tulane, and Colorado could disrupt the established order, while others like Missouri and Iowa State may find themselves moving up or down in the rankings. The next few weeks will determine which teams are truly deserving of a spot in the College Football Playoff, but for now, the rankings have set the stage for an exciting conclusion to the regular season.
If you enjoyed this deep dive into the College Football Playoff rankings, be sure to subscribe to the GSMC Sports Podcast for more expert analysis and updates. Don’t forget to leave a review and share your thoughts on social media! Also, check out more articles and podcasts on our website at gsmcpodcast.com, and for exclusive content, follow our GSMC Sports Network on YouTube for live updates and discussions. Engage with us—let us know your thoughts on the rankings and how you think the playoff picture will unfold as the season progresses!
